There have been several dodgy, grey-market reissues of the Horo records over the years and the latest is a vinyl-only box set, The Mystery of Being, released back in 2011 on the tiny French label, Klimt, which crams the two January 1978 double albums onto three LPs. Sound quality is actually pretty good – certainly better than my crackly needledrops—but at the same time, I suspect these are taken from vinyl sources and then (aggressively) de-noised. Moreover, the sides are excessively long, resulting in diminished dynamic range and susceptibility to noise. Sadly, one side of my copy has a nasty pressing flaw, which causes the stylus to skip—and they are now out-of-print, so it is not so easily replaceable. Bummer.
Although there are neither mastering credits nor any liner notes whatsoever, this set purports to present the music in chronological order, providing recording dates on the labels. According to them, the sessions occurred as follows:
That makes some sort of sense until you get to the last disc, which could have been recorded on any one of those dates. Huh? This is less than helpful and just another indication of this set’s dubious provenance. I would guess that basic tracks for New Steps were recorded on January 2, with overdubbing taking place on January 7. Similarly, basic tracks for Other Voices, Other Blues likely took place on January 8, with overdubbing happening on January 13. That’s just a guess, but that would mirror the usual progression in a multi-track environment. Then again, such was a highly unusual practice for Sonny, so who knows how it went down? As with so much in the Sun Ra discography, not much can be known with certainty except that the music is fantastic.
(continue reading at NuVoid's Sun Ra Sunday)
Although there are neither mastering credits nor any liner notes whatsoever, this set purports to present the music in chronological order, providing recording dates on the labels. According to them, the sessions occurred as follows:
Side One: January 2: My Favorite Things, Moon People, Rome at Twilight, When There is No Sun
Side Two: January 7: Sun Steps, Exactly Like You, Friend and Friendship
Side Three: January 8: The Horo, Sun Sky and Wind
Side Four: January 13: Springtime and Summer Idyll, Constellation
Sides Five and Six: January 2, 7, 8, 13: One Day in Rome, Bridge to the Ninth Dimension, Along the Tiber, Rebellion, The Mystery of Being
That makes some sort of sense until you get to the last disc, which could have been recorded on any one of those dates. Huh? This is less than helpful and just another indication of this set’s dubious provenance. I would guess that basic tracks for New Steps were recorded on January 2, with overdubbing taking place on January 7. Similarly, basic tracks for Other Voices, Other Blues likely took place on January 8, with overdubbing happening on January 13. That’s just a guess, but that would mirror the usual progression in a multi-track environment. Then again, such was a highly unusual practice for Sonny, so who knows how it went down? As with so much in the Sun Ra discography, not much can be known with certainty except that the music is fantastic.
(continue reading at NuVoid's Sun Ra Sunday)
And in Counterpoint:
Ra’s discography is so vast and daunting that at this point one needs to wonder how far down the dregs go. The answer can be found on this lifeless monstrosity of a release, a triple album representing his small ensemble recordings made in Italy circa January ’78. Conceptually, the album seems like a no brainer; you have the mythic Ra leading a remarkably small ensemble with right-hand sax master John Gilmore at his side, covering standards like “My Favorite Things” and “Exactly Like You”. The problem is two-fold. First, Ra picks perhaps the least flattering digital pre-80s tone on his keyboard heard thus far, leaving everything sounding just horribly flat and wonky. When it seems like only Gilmore can save the day, he’s mixed so freakishly loud that it’s nothing short of jarring. Many of the tracks are “ballads” and certainly not invoking the mood Gilmore was shooting for. Whoever was at the mixing board shoves him so far in front it almost makes one forget about the jittery failure of Ra’s choice in dynamic for the arrangements. If one seeks Ra and Gilmore tackling standards they do so with remarkable success on the Sun Sound Pleasure LP that can be purchased for less than the cost of a 3-D movie rather than break the bank on this expensive, ugly set, (which features no notes, pictures or information). A release that only a Frenchman could enjoy, The Mystery of Being is perhaps the least necessary release in Ra’s bloated discography. Steer Clear!
online review from Swingset Magazine
online review from Swingset Magazine
Sun Ra Quartet
The Mystery Of Being
(3-LP Box Set)
Klimt MJJ316 (2011)
1. My Favorite Things 8:11
2. Moon People 7:43
3. Rome At Twilight 5:06
4. When There Is No Sun 4:37
5. Sun Steps 11:29
6. Exactly Like You 6:01
7. Friend And Friendship 6:48
8. The Horo 15:23
9. Sun, Sky, And Wind 7:28
10. Springtime And Summer Idyll 13:25
11. Constellation 9:16
12. One Day In Rome 5:25
13. Bridge On The Ninth Dimension 13:50
14. Along The Tiber 4:03
15. Rebellion 12:18
16. The Mystery Of Being 10:20
-FLAC-
Linked files are interchangeable - all 3 parts
required to open
RS1 + RS2 + RS3
Mega1 + Mega2 + Mega3
FF1 + FF2 + FF3
or
-320-
RS
Mega
FF



great post… great blog!
ReplyDeleteYotte:
ReplyDeleteMany thanks!
Best
Jim
Are my ears and audio sensibilities so far different than the reviewers' ?
ReplyDeleteThere's some really excellent music on these sides, the reviews, to my
way of hearing and thinking, don't really reflect that. Give The Mystery Of Being a fresh listen. I think you'll feel rewarded. I did.
Best
Jim
Awesome! Thanks a lot!
ReplyDeleteDuxiland :-)
woooooow!
ReplyDeletewhat a wonderful gift
thanks a lot!
thank yew, yotte!!!
ReplyDeleteI-)
i really don't care about the reviews of TMOB. as long as they do not say anything bad about 'new steps' or 'other voices, other blues', i'm cool.
ReplyDeletelistening to TMOB, i get reminded of the 'god is more than...' album, but in a slightly slower mode? it is the similar small ensemble setting, and on TMOB sun ra plays heavily in the low keys area of the keyboard, like on GIMT...
I-)
People have been clamoring for legit reissues of the Horo catalog for years, with good reason. Great artists given complete license to do whatever they wanted; top notch production and packaging, what’s not to love? At first it was puzzling why Sonny passed on the grand piano for the old upright. Then when you hear the distant sounding cosmo tones he gets with the muting peddle, it makes perfect sense.
ReplyDeleteI picked up the Sun Ra Horos while visiting friends in Chicago in late 1978. I’ll always treasure the store clerk’s comments as he rang up my stack “Wow, Sun Ra…WOW, two Sun Ras!… THREE SUN RAS!!!”
As for the 2nd review, few things are more useless than reviews that fixate on sound or dexterity while missing the music.
I bought this box a few years ago. The quality of the vinyl is good as is the transfer of the music from an earlier source. yes, it sounds a little thin but with a decent sound system this is easily compensated. So I'am very happy with this box (I've never seen the Horo's) - although a booklet or info sheet would have made the set more complete.
ReplyDeletejesus......why in the world would you even write a review of a sun ra lp? Thanks for all this great stuff
ReplyDeleteI owe the generous uploader of this wonderful album a big thank you for letting me share with him the mastery of Sun Ra & Co. in yet another fabulous '70s incarnation. The Swingset magazine reviewer boggles the mind with his absurd impression of this glorious music. Could he be talking about the same album that, as I write this, is giving me the goosebumps? Nor is the sound of this recording bad at all. Anyway, yotte I appreciate your tireless continuance of this Sun Ra project. I don't have the means of acquiring as many of his albums as I would wish to so for me this gap-filling by your curtesy is immensely helpful. Thank you! Boris from London, UK.
ReplyDelete